PGDM vs MBA know the other side or both side of the coin ! !
PGDM MBA ,we should check annual package ctc or we should check 'take home 'salary /in hand salary '
PGDM or MBA which one is better ,does it really matter in plcmnt !
100% placement assurance does really make any sense or job sustainability and secured job profile matters to us
100% placemnet assurance does really make any sense to you or these are just a' tricky vocabulary' in maximum case
'Things which looks good may not be good to u ,know both side of the coin !!
Keep in mind these facts to choose the right college for you through MAT
Beware of some' tricky vocabulary' for average college when u getting entry through MAT/CMAT or medium lower score in CAT. Never get manipulated or getting scared that “immediately join our college or the seat will be passed on to next “,never ever any tier I level colleges call you with such proposal,because their quality and secured placement is enough to speak,it is just a “fear of missing out “ or “ FoMo” marketing strategy to fill the seats by some average b schools ,sometime some “free admission agency ‘also do this,beware of them(They might have interest from college to push you)
Here are some cases that why 100% placement does not make any sense without job stability.
Case I: What you see : Avilash 25 ,good score in mat , (not in tier I)PGDM (Marketing ) got placed in a reputed MNC with 4.8 L package ctc,he is very happy ,in hometown parents alao celebrate this with relatives,he also makes plan how to balance a congruous life style with bank loan EMI.Everything looks fine
What is it: He joined the job and asked to take a 2wheeler with license immediately,he buys it taking another loan burden then he find out that he will be liable for selling their 'unsought' products not the star products,he got shocked more when he saw the pay slip as he has no idea that annual ctc package is not his "take home " or "in hand" salary !!! ,he has to resign within few months
Case II :What you see : Gitanjali Banerjee,24+ PGDM (finance guy) satisfactory score in CMAT, always dreamt a profile investment banker,market research,risk analystetc) She got placed in famous icixy bank with ctc 6L annual, she also was very happy to enjoy her first financial freedom already planned some gifts for parents and siblings .(She did not checked the job profile or according to the placement norms of college she has to accept first chance any how ).
What you cant see: She joined the banks insurnc job profile,she is unable to fulfill their unrealistic sales quota of insurnc,even her salary slip was shocking than declared ctc package ,she has no idea about that ctc annual package is not in hand,within few months she was coerced to 'put her resignation on table due to inefficiency" She is in deep sea now!
1) Choose ur field first ( sales/ core finance/ HR /financial product sales) for sales many time having 2 wheeler and license is mandatory,check it with plcmnt officer directly
CHECK ONE THING PROPERLY :
When you are choosing an average b school you will find some reputed world giant mnc names like Apple,Microsoft,Amazon,Google,Audi are flashing in placement brochure;check whether it is placement in 3rd party vendor/franchaisee or direct company payroll.
2) Check then average in hand salary /take home amount always; not check the annual package or CTC(as these are not your in hand salary,these are quiet virtual, the CTC package includes Telephone bill ,HRA,LTC, Mediclaim, incentive,Bonus, PF,TA,DA,food coupon,gratuity,insurnc etc )clever before investment
You may be a darling student of ur college (Tier II/III level)as u r investing huge bt may not be for corporate !
3)Check the job profile sustainability,secured profile or 'bulk hire and fire' profile
4) For finance check the job profile is core finance (investment banker,Risk mngmnt, Asset mngmnt, Law-Taxation,Auditing,Actuary,derivative analyst,credit analyst,hedging ,Market research, Business analyst(eg Merger &Acquisition)etc ) o
profile is for
financial product sales(offered by tier II/III level colleges mainly)
(insurnc,mutual fund sales,demat account sales,relationship manager,corporate credit sales,broking sales job),it is good to have 55-60% upto graduation for core finance profile as mnc s demand it
5) Mainly core finance profile,it is good to have 55-60% graduation for this profile as mnc demands many time
(investment banker,
asset mngmnt,risk mngmnt
,Treasry mngmnt,Law-taxation,derivative analyst,credit analyst,market research) are avil through higher CAT score college
Better to check this with the plcmnt officer directly
Sometime u will see many govt under taking banks name in plcmnt co,remember ur profile may be in insurnce sales/credit card sales etc which is not under govt undertaking it is the separate business by the "Bank Group''as Govt unsertaking recrtcmnt can be done from college directly at any case can be done by IBPS only
Example SBI's Banking segemnt is under govt undertaking but insurnc business is under SBI group pvt partnrshp
Make linkedin profile to chat with college alumni to get the exact average picture of job suatainability and take home salary rather than the current stusents view
6) Be clever before investment/ bank loan ,take a linked in tour to chat woth college alumni so that can get the real picture
7)Never ever rely on any 'free admossion agency ' as they may have some monetary interst to push u in college
8)Be sure with CAT or u have to play the gamble at ur own risk
9) Never get manipulated some 'promotional vocabulary' like free laptop,foreigj tour,foreign tie upforeign exposure because u r paying for all and at the end of the day u will take a secured job not the 'free wifi campus 'to home
10) never get mamipulated by the views of current student as being a part of the systemm,they cant criticize it
11) Never get diverted by seeing few win win faces ,as exception cant be an example ,know the average situation
Even among those winning faces the job profile suatainability make their destination,so be clever
12) You can enjoy cold drink of brand x and also like financial service of famous bank Axy but that does not mean u can also enjoy it as an employee when ur profile is not stable/secured or the profile is hardcore insurnc sales,if u confortable with this then go
13)In case of MBA IT placement check the job profile is abour corporate software sales or managing a software team work force
14)Core marketing profile is avail in mainly CAT colleges and rest of other generally provide u sales profile,it is tough to stable in a unsought product sales like water purifier,corporate sales,real estate sales, credit card sales,mutual fund sales,corporate credit sales ,or fmcg sales of 'questionble productsnof branded company(check bcg matrix google)
Sought products are medicine and FMCG 'star' 'cash cow' products check it with the placement officer
Always try HR through CAT otherwise initial salary may be poor though ctc is shown high,and Hr is not so called profit making part and in present due to purchasing power disparity in buyers market HR profile is not entertained by mnc s
If you have MAT higher score 95 above chase tier I colleges first Public sector :
1) Simsree Govt of Maharashtra(98 can apply,check upto final list)
2) PUMBA Pune univ
Both are such having fee is low bt RoI is good and quiet sustainable secured job profile comparatively
3) NIBM pune (cmat/cat/atma) writing skill test,PI
Private sector :
XIME BLORE,Bimtech noida,Great lakes chennai,IFMR
If not get in can think about also Xime Kochi ,Christ blore,IPE hyderabad .
PGDM MBA ,we should check annual package ctc or we should check 'take home 'salary /in hand salary '
PGDM or MBA which one is better ,does it really matter in plcmnt !
100% placement assurance does really make any sense or job sustainability and secured job profile matters to us
100% placemnet assurance does really make any sense to you or these are just a' tricky vocabulary' in maximum case
'Things which looks good may not be good to u ,know both side of the coin !!
Keep in mind these facts to choose the right college for you through MAT
Beware of some' tricky vocabulary' for average college when u getting entry through MAT/CMAT or medium lower score in CAT. Never get manipulated or getting scared that “immediately join our college or the seat will be passed on to next “,never ever any tier I level colleges call you with such proposal,because their quality and secured placement is enough to speak,it is just a “fear of missing out “ or “ FoMo” marketing strategy to fill the seats by some average b schools ,sometime some “free admission agency ‘also do this,beware of them(They might have interest from college to push you)
Here are some cases that why 100% placement does not make any sense without job stability.
Case I: What you see : Avilash 25 ,good score in mat , (not in tier I)PGDM (Marketing ) got placed in a reputed MNC with 4.8 L package ctc,he is very happy ,in hometown parents alao celebrate this with relatives,he also makes plan how to balance a congruous life style with bank loan EMI.Everything looks fine
What is it: He joined the job and asked to take a 2wheeler with license immediately,he buys it taking another loan burden then he find out that he will be liable for selling their 'unsought' products not the star products,he got shocked more when he saw the pay slip as he has no idea that annual ctc package is not his "take home " or "in hand" salary !!! ,he has to resign within few months
Case II :What you see : Gitanjali Banerjee,24+ PGDM (finance guy) satisfactory score in CMAT, always dreamt a profile investment banker,market research,risk analystetc) She got placed in famous icixy bank with ctc 6L annual, she also was very happy to enjoy her first financial freedom already planned some gifts for parents and siblings .(She did not checked the job profile or according to the placement norms of college she has to accept first chance any how ).
What you cant see: She joined the banks insurnc job profile,she is unable to fulfill their unrealistic sales quota of insurnc,even her salary slip was shocking than declared ctc package ,she has no idea about that ctc annual package is not in hand,within few months she was coerced to 'put her resignation on table due to inefficiency" She is in deep sea now!
1) Choose ur field first ( sales/ core finance/ HR /financial product sales) for sales many time having 2 wheeler and license is mandatory,check it with plcmnt officer directly
CHECK ONE THING PROPERLY :
When you are choosing an average b school you will find some reputed world giant mnc names like Apple,Microsoft,Amazon,Google,Audi are flashing in placement brochure;check whether it is placement in 3rd party vendor/franchaisee or direct company payroll.
2) Check then average in hand salary /take home amount always; not check the annual package or CTC(as these are not your in hand salary,these are quiet virtual, the CTC package includes Telephone bill ,HRA,LTC, Mediclaim, incentive,Bonus, PF,TA,DA,food coupon,gratuity,insurnc etc )clever before investment
You may be a darling student of ur college (Tier II/III level)as u r investing huge bt may not be for corporate !
3)Check the job profile sustainability,secured profile or 'bulk hire and fire' profile
4) For finance check the job profile is core finance (investment banker,Risk mngmnt, Asset mngmnt, Law-Taxation,Auditing,Actuary,derivative analyst,credit analyst,hedging ,Market research, Business analyst(eg Merger &Acquisition)etc ) o
profile is for
financial product sales(offered by tier II/III level colleges mainly)
(insurnc,mutual fund sales,demat account sales,relationship manager,corporate credit sales,broking sales job),it is good to have 55-60% upto graduation for core finance profile as mnc s demand it
5) Mainly core finance profile,it is good to have 55-60% graduation for this profile as mnc demands many time
(investment banker,
asset mngmnt,risk mngmnt
,Treasry mngmnt,Law-taxation,derivative analyst,credit analyst,market research) are avil through higher CAT score college
Better to check this with the plcmnt officer directly
Sometime u will see many govt under taking banks name in plcmnt co,remember ur profile may be in insurnce sales/credit card sales etc which is not under govt undertaking it is the separate business by the "Bank Group''as Govt unsertaking recrtcmnt can be done from college directly at any case can be done by IBPS only
Example SBI's Banking segemnt is under govt undertaking but insurnc business is under SBI group pvt partnrshp
Make linkedin profile to chat with college alumni to get the exact average picture of job suatainability and take home salary rather than the current stusents view
6) Be clever before investment/ bank loan ,take a linked in tour to chat woth college alumni so that can get the real picture
7)Never ever rely on any 'free admossion agency ' as they may have some monetary interst to push u in college
8)Be sure with CAT or u have to play the gamble at ur own risk
9) Never get manipulated some 'promotional vocabulary' like free laptop,foreigj tour,foreign tie upforeign exposure because u r paying for all and at the end of the day u will take a secured job not the 'free wifi campus 'to home
10) never get mamipulated by the views of current student as being a part of the systemm,they cant criticize it
11) Never get diverted by seeing few win win faces ,as exception cant be an example ,know the average situation
Even among those winning faces the job profile suatainability make their destination,so be clever
12) You can enjoy cold drink of brand x and also like financial service of famous bank Axy but that does not mean u can also enjoy it as an employee when ur profile is not stable/secured or the profile is hardcore insurnc sales,if u confortable with this then go
13)In case of MBA IT placement check the job profile is abour corporate software sales or managing a software team work force
14)Core marketing profile is avail in mainly CAT colleges and rest of other generally provide u sales profile,it is tough to stable in a unsought product sales like water purifier,corporate sales,real estate sales, credit card sales,mutual fund sales,corporate credit sales ,or fmcg sales of 'questionble productsnof branded company(check bcg matrix google)
Sought products are medicine and FMCG 'star' 'cash cow' products check it with the placement officer
Always try HR through CAT otherwise initial salary may be poor though ctc is shown high,and Hr is not so called profit making part and in present due to purchasing power disparity in buyers market HR profile is not entertained by mnc s
If you have MAT higher score 95 above chase tier I colleges first Public sector :
1) Simsree Govt of Maharashtra(98 can apply,check upto final list)
2) PUMBA Pune univ
Both are such having fee is low bt RoI is good and quiet sustainable secured job profile comparatively
3) NIBM pune (cmat/cat/atma) writing skill test,PI
Private sector :
XIME BLORE,Bimtech noida,Great lakes chennai,IFMR
If not get in can think about also Xime Kochi ,Christ blore,IPE hyderabad .
Sir can you suggest me few management entrance tests so that we can prepare our mindset from now..??
ReplyDelete😯ডেকার্স লেনে চা খাবো চল কবে যাবি😊😊
DeleteDearAyan,It is ecstatic that u decide,the adverse truth is that many tier II/III level collge plcmnt depends on the plcmnt officers holding,if s/he suddenly resign u guys r in deep sea,this the conginizable reason why these plcmnts are volatile every year,but in Tier I mat level college or higher CAT level colleges plcmnt depends on the collge's brand equityby which corporate lured with a sustainable job with good take home/in hand salary,plz ensure 95 in MAT and apply the above colleges or try to bell the CAT properlydont play the gamble with such huge bank loan burden /investment
ReplyDeleteSir, i scored 48.6% in my graduation and I want to do pgdm. Can you please suggest me some college? How about jims kalkaji?
ReplyDeleteHope you read the blog and know the pros and cons if your percntl is lower in CAT mat read it again.
DeleteI cant make comment on individual,advice u to check JIMS rohini 1st
You can check the job profile sustainability from the plcmnt officer also average'takenhome "salary not the ctc annual package,(example: check the bank job profile is it core finance,asst mngr trainee job or financial product sales job(if u r okay with this then go ,similarly in sales check with linkedin alumni about the work culture,profile stability or it is just 'bulk hire and fire' profile,check it also by quora.com mention ur percntl ,
Many mnc s of core finance job profile demands 55-60% in sales some top mnc having good job profile demands 50% ,kindly if possible visit college plcmnt ofcr directly to check this, be clever u r also a huge paying cuatomer ao u have full right to know both side of the coin
Sir, what are best tier || colleges for mba marketing in Pune
ReplyDeleteDear Subham,Suppose you have taken admission in tier II Colleges seeing that this year your dream job profile there but suddenly your placement officer resigns for another better offer,and the next substitute has not very strong hold in corporates and s/he lines up insurnc company under banks brand name! who will responsable,so be sure with tier I OR HIGHER CAt or dont take loan risk ,you can have 100 placement support bt job sustainability may be question,better to ask college alumni through linked in
Deletecan u please tell me that which one is better one from the following:-
ReplyDelete1. JIM's(kalka or Rohini)
2. Fostima
3. Asia pacific
4. Mangalmay
I don't have any financial support nd i'm looking to go with bank loan for studies.
Is it good move or not.
Hii Puneet ,
DeleteThanks for writing.Tell me which field do you prefer in job (sales,Hr,Financial Sales,Core finance)? You are taking loan burden so,I will not recommend you the above any , what is your percentile ? You can check in Gnanamani namakakkal,Chennai (lower cost around 1.6L) or if you have 95 around Mat,can suggest you some good with low cost high RoI.Give me the info which I asked kindly to serve you better
can u please tell me that which one is better one from the following:-
ReplyDelete1. JIM's(kalka or Rohini)
2. Fostima
3. Asia pacific
4. Mangalmay
I don't have any financial support nd i'm looking to go with bank loan for studies.
Is it good move or not.
Sir please tell me which one college i should choose. IPE Hydrabad or XIME Kochi.My cat percentile is 89.
ReplyDeleteXime Kochi,you can use the xavearian sticker in vehicle life time !😊 Actually xime K is very new but itis promising as the I came to know you may have the xime blore advntg during placement as their mutual centralised strategy of placement with Xime B, means both college students many time can seat for same placement tenure;may be you have to go Xime blore campus to attend the interview,as per my understanding XIME is doing this to oxydised the budding new one,abd it is blessing for you(though verify this secret with placement head or admission head,as permy memory I have heard this from first batch alumni.
ReplyDeleteThough IPE banking finance is too good recent you can see many financialproduct sales profile co are participating,better to avoid those profile ,also visit the campus for better understading before investment;Ohh congrats too to bell the CAT decently quite.
If you think banking finance then think first NIBM Pune an automous establish by RBI and banks in 1969,only 120 seats ! so get hurry,you have quiet handsome score to chase.
Xime Kochi,you can use the xavearian sticker in vehicle life time !😊 Actually xime K is very new but itis promising as the I came to know you may have the xime blore advntg during placement as their mutual centralised strategy of placement with Xime B, means both college students many time can seat for same placement tenure;may be you have to go Xime blore campus to attend the interview,as per my understanding XIME is doing this to oxydised the budding new one,abd it is blessing for you(though verify this secret with placement head or admission head,as permy memory I have heard this from first batch alumni.
ReplyDeleteThough IPE banking finance is too good recent you can see many financialproduct sales profile co are participating,better to avoid those profile ,also visit the campus for better understading before investment;Ohh congrats too to bell the CAT decently quite.
If you think banking finance then think first NIBM Pune an automous establish by RBI and banks in 1969,only 120 seats ! so get hurry,you have quiet handsome score to chase.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteHii Ryan, I personally request you to better to try BIMM pune or Xime Kochi (If you have natinal level score card as Xime Kochi placement is centrally attached with Xime blore,this is advntg for you,though you may need to go Xime blore campus for campus interview)
DeleteFor sales profile hope you have 2 wheeler with license.
Now I am coming to the point,I have yet not interacted personally with any ubs alumni but there are some question ,college provide yiu duel progrm mba +pgdm ,here pgdm is aicte approved but mba is affilaiate dwith a foreign univ if I am not wrong (kindly rectify if I am wrong)but in india the autonomous progrm is valid with aicte approval and the mba is valid with ugc revognised univ affiliation,otherwise any mnc can challenge your validation of degree for this IIPM has to shut down all cmpuses in all India basis
Read https://www.google.co.in/amp/wap.business-standard.com/article-amp/current-affairs/iipm-to-shut-down-all-campuses-october-onwards-115070201044_1.html
So if in future anybody challenge this in court you may face problem.I am really unable to understand how is it possible to carry 2 full time degree at same time period !
I noticed one thing also in this college current students has started giving review(it should be an alumni review with after placement experience) Hope system is not coercing them to do so for promotion basis.In review also pupil are admiring with green eco friendly campus,good wifi,exposure,foreignnaffikiation blah blah....could not find a single coherent answer about job profile of the company,after placement job satisfaction,stability.
But at the end of the day you will take a secured job with good in hand salary to home not the lush green wifi campus to home.
If you have satifactory answer of the above question,you can go or try Mat once again to abstain yourself of playing gamble.Make a linkedin profile today to chat with senior alumni.
If you are giving mat once again then chase Simsree, Pumba,Xime blore ,Bimtech noida(PGDM RM accept Mat) Great lakes chennai,IFMR.
'Beware the ideas of March'
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteHi, subhajit
ReplyDeleteI scored 99.62 percentile in MAY MAT 2017 and have already applied for SIMSREE,SIMSR,PUMBA pune through DTE CAP process.can you please suggest me some more good colleges ?
Well done !
DeleteIn public sector you have already applied ,it is cost friendly 1.6L around too)u can chase private sector few top tier I (if seats are remain vacant there luckily) Xime blore,Bimtech Noida-RM,IFMr,Greqt lakes chennai,NIBM Pune.
If unable to get into that can think about Xime kochi,IPE hyderabad(banking finance),IIRM hyderabad(risk mngmnt,Business analyst),BIMM Pune can also be in your 2nd list of choice.
Hope you have 55-60% for core finance as it is good to have and two wheeler if you want sales job.
Make a linkedin & quora profile today to chat with alumni .
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteHi Sir, I have scored 48% in Graduation and going to appear in JEMAT 2017 for mba in Kolkata.. How is the placement scenario in WBUT colleges in Kolkata?
ReplyDeleteHii Divyanshu,
DeleteThanks for A2A.Here we have a problem of having(50% is taken as minimum safe criteria) 48% , as you may not have problem to get admission as an welcomed customer but you will hardly get a good bschool or job profile as I mentioned now a days many core finance company demands 55-60% and for sales some stable good profile in fmcg giants demand 50 %.
So check this directly with the placement officer with face to face talk.Otherwise the investment will be in vain if you are in uncertain profile of unrealistic target sales.
So your discretion is needed.You have to think whether you will take risk or not because we cant change the past catastrophe.
Decide first which profile is your cupof tea (sales,core finance,financial sales)
Hope you read the blog attentively.
I can only recommend you BIBS (check whether it allows jemat or not,also clearly have words with placement head about this 48% obstacle impact on your favourite field of job) I would not like to recommend other as remember 100% placement does not make any sense without job stability.
hi Sir,
ReplyDeleteI got 81.7 percentile in may MAT 2017.Can u suggest me good colleges according to my score?
Hii friend,
DeleteIt would be better if you got this in dec/feb mat as at that time chances are higher of having vacant seats in good colleges, you can check Bimm pune,Xime chennai (it is new but Xime is trusted brand name,though check it properly or check if Xime kochi allows May mat or not), IPE hyderabad (banking finance),IIRM hyderabad (risk mngnnt or business analyst).But best is to give September(focus in accuracy not much attempt to get into top tier I) to cleanesed off 'all the ghosts of christmass past'.
Hope you read the blog well.
Feel free to write.
Hi sir, i need to know a detail info. for some colleges as i got offer from IPE hyderabad in finance and IFIM( PGDM- GEN). which college you suggest me to choose for better future career.
ReplyDeleteHii friend, If you get ifim -finance and IPE- banking finance then think or try also in NIBM pune for finance or attempt september mat once again to chase Xime blore.
DeleteOr check if there is seats avail in MDI murshidabad, mat accepts,CAT preferred. Check this it is budding college of MDI group but improving robustly with MDI brand name.
DeleteHi Sir,my name is Jai.
ReplyDeleteCan you tell me about NDIM New Delhi tughlakabad...Really confused, my MAT score was 97%ile and Cmat was 90
Hii Jai,
DeleteCongrtas ! You have done well.I will advice you to attend Sept,Dec Mat as top tier I schools mainly participating on that;if you have this score in Dec/Sept you will definately get tier I college (Sept/Dec comparatively slight tougher than May).I want to abstain myself to comment on that very college.
Do not spoil your score to choose any average college where you can take a easy entry with any score card. Bschool students often have 1/2 year gap for Cat/Mat preperation.Make a prudent dicisive decision to choose a lifetime career ,as probably you are investing/bank loan burden huge last time .
It is better to message in quora. Feel free to write.
Good luck !
This was my Feb MAT score and Sep MAT would be too late to be appeared, since I am looking forward to take admission by this year only. Please suggest me, how to proceed.
ReplyDeleteHii jai , I can suggest you then chase the above tier I mentioned in blog (but hardly/luckily could find seats there) think Xime Kochi,IIRM hyderabad(risk management,business analyst,IPE hyderabad(banking finance),MDI Murshidabad(it is nascent but improving rapidly for Mdi gurgaon brand,accepts mat but prefers Cat.
DeleteI could not find the reason why you are too late because if you chase colleges in february probability was quiet higher to get a tier I colleges, How ever check these now.You have not mentioned your area of interst in job,further kindly inbox me in quora as everything can not be written in here or call me 5-6pm,try my best to guide you.
If you don't mind...may I know your email ID. If you can't share it here...mine is jai.clrk1993@gmail.com. I request you to please revert me on this email Id..Seeking for your suggestion eagerly.
ReplyDeleteSir I got 98.74 percentile in mat which is the best college in which I can apply
ReplyDeleteCongrats friend for the achievement, but is tough to get best colleges through Mat May as you can luckily find seats vacant till may mat,those toptier b schools are participating Dec/Sept mat.
DeleteCheck the bschooles mentioned in above latest discussions with 'Jai' and in blog also check this https://www.quora.com/I-have-a-composite-score-of-731-5-800-and-overall-percentile-of-97-38-in-MAT-MAY-2017-Which-colleges-should-I-apply-for?share=9859c1b3&srid=hyXZ4
Or try Sept mat .Do not make a wrong decision in hurry as you deserve better according to score.
Feel free to write .
Good luck !
Sir is pibm is good for pgdm?
ReplyDeleteHii friend,Why you are not attempting september Mat for better hope as thing which comes easily is not worthy.
DeleteWhich profile do you like(Hr,sales,core finance,Financial sales)as job ?
You have not mentioned your score also.
Hi sir i got 87.63%ile in cmat but i didnt cnvrt welingkar dalmia colleges can you suggest some good college ?
ReplyDeleteHii Unknown,
DeleteOops the duo are too good you missed. Already this year session has been started in maximum tier I colleges though you luckily can have chances in XIME Kochi or MDI Murshidabad or try september Mat once again to mitigate the invetment risk.Can have a look for TSM Madurai too but you have not mentioned your area of interest in MBA,so it is not good to shoot in the dark.
Sir what about iims pune...its a pgdm college..it is best or not
ReplyDeleteHii abhishek,You may be talking about iims pune,may be a budding college,i would not recommend this.You can think BIMM pune as it is better than other bottom pyramid or go for Mat once again.
Deletehello subhajit,i completed my graduation @ 2015 since then i have been preparing for banking but some how i could not clear the main of any exam as the level of banking examination is on a par with cal level..so is it prudent decision to appear in cmat on january ..my age is 24 now and i have no work experience in my bag..can u guide me regarding this matter..thank you in advance.
ReplyDeleteHii Sayantan,thanks for wrting.Nay,I also heard about banking exams become a meritless speed accuracy based exam day by day and calibrating for last few years rapidly.Do not loss hope as thing which comes easily is not worthy but if you want to get rid off this monotonous exam preparation can think Cmat as taste changer if you are able to get cmat tier I colleges like NLDalmia(finance),Great lakes chennai (finance),Bimtech,Imt nagpur or hyderabad its good ,and do not think about the gap as it is common for bschools as students are taking this time for CAT preperation and about money,you can put these excuses easily but firmly.If get tier I then go or prepare for IBPS CGL etc. You have nothing to loss as,as per my knowledge banking exam session starts in June to Novmbr so after this gap period you can think Dec Mat and Cmat,so there is no collision,who knows a lucrative door may be waiting there. Hope you have safegurad 55 % above in graduation.
Deletei would like to contact you through personal chat option..do you have some ? then please do share..i would be grateful to you..my whatsapp number is 8981482232
Deletei'm egarly waiting for your reply..please do contact with me....if you share your email id ..that will also serve my purpose..thank you..:)
DeleteSir, Plz tell me which one is good...& plz arrange them..decending order
ReplyDelete1. BHU-MBA(through CAT),Varanasi
2. IISWBM-MBA,Kolkata
3. BIBS,Ballygunge, Kolkata
4. Globsyn Business School,Kolkata
I have no direct interaction with BHU Mba alumni but in genral discussion pupil and people appretiate it as lowest cost(around 1L)and according to investment return is good,try to catch an alumni /current student of BHU and check the offered job profiles or interact directly with placement officer,pupil are of trust with BHU brand name to lure corporate though check it from horse's mouth through linkedin profile.
ReplyDeleteNow in Kolkata 1) IISWB&M kolkata low cost with good ROI (being india's oldest b school is an advantage)
2)MDI Murshidabad finance is doing well
3)Army institute Kolkata
4)Bibs Finance(if the previous placement officer is still there as in our time(13-15)/seniors time too it gave good stable profiles core finance as much as possible)
Sry cant recommend Globsyn,better to give next CMAT.
Hi Sir! Pls help me to select a good B school in Kolkata! Tell me the names of top 5 b schools according to the best placement and reasonable fees structure!I have a lot of confusion,because the consultancy NGO's are misguiding us
ReplyDeleteHii Nilanjan,
DeleteThanks for A2A.
Hope you read the blog alreadygood to Void consultancy/ngo/agent as they will only make money from college by pushing you,so according to this in Kolkata I can suggest you
1) IISWB&M kolkata low cost with good ROI (being india's oldest b school is an advantage)
2)MDI Murshidabad finance is doing well(new but mdi gurgaon brand name is advntg)
3)Army institute Kolkata
4)Bibs Finance(if the previous placement officer is still there as in our time(13-15)/seniors time too it gave good stable profiles core finance as much as possible)
Though you have not mentioned your score/your area of ineterest profile.Hope this will help you to make a prudent decision.
Thank you sir,i am bsc food and Nutrition honours student,So I want to go for HR,
DeleteI have visited BIBS Kolkata,it is good for finance,but I don't know that is it also good for HR?
I also came to know it is not AICTE approved.
I have given MAT,so I'm searching for a good B school accepting MAT and is good for HR and provide best placement. What about EIILM BHARATIYA VIDYA BHAVAN?
There is a mixed view about harti vidya bhavan,so you need to make a linkedin profile to catch the alumni of HR.eiilm is not recommended by me,you have not mentioned your score card but still for HR except iiswb&m i could not find a similar option.
DeleteThrough MAT for HR core job profile you should choose Xavearian group colleges(XISS ranchi,Xime blore,Xime kochi,Xib) do not tale risk or gove next cmat or february mat ,otherwise due to lack of HR profile you may be foisted in sales profile(it was happened in our college).
Kindly check the situation of MDI murshidabad,the big trusted brand mdi gurgaon is behind this but the college is quiet new.
Best wishes;
Subhajit
Hi Sir! Pls help me to select a good B school in Kolkata! Tell me the names of top 5 b schools according to the best placement and reasonable fees structure!I have a lot of confusion,because the consultancy NGO's are misguiding us
ReplyDeleteDear subhajit da, thnkyu for opening eyes of many i want your serious help regarding mba admission my mat score 89 cmat 81 options ipe jaipuria IISWBM. IISWBM etar mba public systems jawa thik hobe? Placement roi kamon.bujte parchina plz plz help me . 1953 er college many are saying mixed reviews
ReplyDeleteআইআইএসডব্লুবিএম বাকিদের তুলনায় অনেক ভালো । কস্ট কম প্লাস জব প্রোফাইল ভালো । আশা করি ক্যাটে ভালো রাঙ্ক আছে তোমার। ইউ ইউল বি ফরচুনেট এনাফ যদি আইআইএসডব্লোবিএম তোমায় সিলেক্ট করে। আইআইএসডাব্লুবিএম রিটেল/হিউম্যান রিসোর্স এসবের জন্য অন্যতম কিন্তু পাবলিক সিস্টেম টা জানা নেই। লিঙ্কডইন অ্যালুমনি কে অ্যাড কর এই সেক্টরে তার থেকে পুরো আসল তথ্য পাবে।আগে নিজেকে জিজ্ঞেস করো তুমি সেলস না ফিনান্স না এইচআর অফিস জব চাও।মনে রেখো একই সেক্টরে পয়সা আর শান্তি একসাথে পাবেনা অন্তত এই স্কোর কার্ডে।সেলসে পয়সা আছে শান্তি কম আবার কোর ফিনান্স ,এইচ আর এ পয়সা কম কিন্তু জব স্যাটিসফেকশন বেশি।
DeleteThanks for the reply shubhajit da unfortunately ami cat likhini this year mba public system e transport logistics ekta branch ache ami interested
DeleteAmi mainly operations people handling retail eirom e job khujchi sales finance not interested So ipe te general pgdm OR IISWBM PUBLIC SYSTEMS ..etatei puro confused..naki abar NEXT YEAR CAT DIE ARO BHALO COLLEGE E TRY KORBO.AM WORKING CURRENTLY.E BOCHOR ADMISSION NILE BHALO HOY :)
কোন সেক্টের কি প্রোফাইলে কাজ করছো জানালে সুবিধা হতো। অনেক স্টুডেন্ট ক্যাটের জন্য ইয়ার ড্রপ দেয় কিন্তু যদি সায়েন্সের না হও তাহলে ক্যাটে ভালো স্কোর করা চাপের আছে। সেটা ভেবে নিও।লজিটিক্সে মূলত কোর লজিস্টিক ম্যানেজমেন্ট প্রোফাইল গুলো এ ক্যাটাগরির স্কুলে সীমাবদ্ধ কিন্তু বি ক্যাটাগরির কলেছে লজিনিক্স বলে অঁইয়ে সেলসে ঠিলা হয় (যেমন নেট থেকে অজানা ডেটা নিয়ে ফোন করে বা তাদের সাথে দেখা করে তাকে তোমার কম্শানির ক্লায়েন্ট বানানো মানে সেই কম্পানির সমস্ত কুরিয়ার অর্ডার যেন তোমরা পাও)তুমি আজই লিঙ্কড ইন এ প্রোফাইল বানিয়ে ঐ দুটো কলেজের নাম প্লাস ফিল্ডের নাম লিঙ্কডইনে লেখ,যেসব সিনিয়র পাবে তাদের অ্যাড করো এবং প্রফেশনালি মেসেজ করো(স্যার বলবে অবশ্যই এবং গ্রামাটিকাল এরর যেন না হয় নাহলে রিপ্লাই পেতে দেরি হতে পারে)তবে আইআইএসডব্লুবিএম আইপিই এর থেকে ভালো এটা বলা যায়। তবে তোমার সেগমেন্ট একটু আলাদা আর এমনি পিজিডিএম করলে আইপিই ও তোমাকে হার্ডকোর সেলসের জব নিতে বাধ্য করতে পারে।ভাবো এবং নিজেকে অ্যানালাইসিস করো...হঠকারী সিদ্ধান্ত মুশকিলে ফেলতে পারে।আমি নিজেও সবটা জানি তা নয় তবে কিছুটা তো জানিই 😊তাড়াহুড়োয় ভুল সিদ্ধান্ত থেকে ধৈর্য্য ধরে এগোনো ভালো
DeleteThanks again subhajit da ami IT te btech digital marketing coordination eisob kaj ei exp hoeche, songe oi ektu social media support etc etc ami programming line theke dure tai pgdm er kotha bhabchi. Amar mone hoy cat xat next year otai thikthobe
DeleteBeing a btech guy it ratifies and fortify your statement so try for cat(if not possible then cmat will be a easy cup of tea of yours. Never be an odstrusive as it hapeens we were unable to make a decision in early 18,you cant change the past but have a better future. Remember you do not need to attempt much more just attempt few but accurately no wild guess which backfires you, can say an unwritten sacrosanct rule or tactics to crack the nut.Never be a victim of procrastination during this preperation. You have enough time to prepare.You can also think PGDBF(banking finance) of bank of baroda,syndicate,ubi (avoid pvt bank icici,axis)your bank will send you to manipal for the degree and offer job after that.If % criteria permits can try this exam too. It is little tough but safe path.Best wishes
DeleteHi Sir,
ReplyDeleteI had quitted my IT job for my MAH-cet prep but I couldn't scored well this year(60%).I have also given Sept MAT2017 and scored 561 marks. I am wiling to do my MBA this year only , please suggest some good colleges or advise me in my future step as i am frustrated and worried about what should be my next move in my career.
Mat and CMAT is not so tough but tricky,you have to answer all section with same importance but accuracy must otherwise your rank will climb down desperately. If you are a science guy then it would not be a tough nut for you. My only advice is to give emtrance once again as you cant buy iPhone with rupees 561,you can have chinese bombs only.Never get frustrated do a break/tour and practice meditation to overcome it.Nothing lasts forever😊Time is the best medicine.
DeleteThese are great examples about choosing the right college and getting placed by the college in a job that you are good at. We all should look at terms and conditions put forth by the firm before we get placed and are later on forced to put down our papers and resign from the post with humiliation and educational loan haunting us forever. Visit: https://www.itm.edu/
ReplyDeletePupil/students can go anywhere but they should know and have full right to check the reality with good and stable return.3/4yr ago also ot was too easy to make fool candidate with some parrot ranting review of and using flamboyant vocabulary like 'exposure',foreign tour,free wifi,free laptop,lush green campus of 10 acre etc. But things are changing with net availability and platform like Quora/blog. What is the significance of this web address of itm here.I could not get this sir☺
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteHow is BIMM,pune for PGDM Marketing? Can i get a good marketing profile after completion of course or i have to be satisfied with sales job?
ReplyDeleteIt is better among average. Though this year placement report is not very clear as students are ranting about amazon package only in their reviews and in quora also. They want to make some benefits,as they claim just application through them and get 300 rupees off ! It looks like they are behaving like consultancy who can give you the so called 1,000rupees form of college in free of cost and by which the consultacy firm make cut money from college.I dont know why current students have started this form selling business,is it also part of their internship if they will unable to stable in job profile.Even in our ncr based college asked our juniors to write 'a win win' review about college who have entered campus in just one month ago.So the way is to you can mail the placement officer(got mail in site)and ask the full list of comapnies participating for sales marketing with the 'JOB PROFILE'.It makes a formidable sense to you if they revert you coherently with full data without hiding anything.If you do not want to go in hardcore sales then try brand management,market research,product manager etc(last one sales is a part but not hardcore and senior position not merely sales man)and for sales arrange a 2 wheeler with license.
DeleteEnter your comment...I have been selected for xime kochin ( 93 percentile in mat) fees is around 12 lakh. I have to pay the initial amount of 20000 by 17 april 2018. should i wait for bimm result ..as I have given the interview.in few days merit list will be out. I have got 88 percentile in mhcet 93 percentile in mat what other options I have? should I go for xime? my problem with bimm is its batch size and only few... get package of 6-7 lakh rest satisfy with 4-5 lakh..please help sir..I have very less time
ReplyDeleteI may be right or wrong but if I had to make decision I will choose to use 'Xavearian' sticker on my car.See I will not join bimm as if I make dinner for 3 and another day make for 9 definately the taste will differ including my presenation skill for 9. As resource is same and stagnant but acceptors are increased by 3 times. Similary the famous and my favourite 'Dada boudi mutton biriyaani' detoriates their level during durga puja season in terms of taste and service as at that time they also have same resource but they have to satisfy ample number of pooja visitor's hunger.So I used to take it in anytime except durga pooja season.I will not choose the fish market
DeleteYaah...you are write, in college every body is ranting about amazon and vedanta but they glorify the 1% or .5 % of total intake of 420/350 around.Every students are tryting to sell the college form any how and they posted link(probably they have some major interest,I hope they are not coerced to work as consultancy agent).Why students are so desperate to sell college form like an agent,is it the placement part ?
Empty vessel sounds much !Though I not questioning the amazon job profile is amazing or not or the take home salary but question is 3 or 4 student cant bring the average of 420.
Even the xime kochi senior batch alumni told me(probably first or second batch)that students were given xime bangalore campus interview offer to promote the new xime kochi a milestone.If the advantage is still on it will be an advantage for you.In general also xavearian groups are good in core finance and HR.Do not run behind package think quality placement and job satisfaction first.
I am not foisting my views but again tell you if I were you,I will go for Xime.
Hope you will make a prudent decision.Sorry for the patience you have shown.I was at work.
Cheers;
Subhajit
thank you sir
Deletesir,i scored 78% in mat (dec).Can u pls suggest me some good colleges in delhi/noida.
ReplyDeleteDear Himanshu,
DeleteIt is rueful to say but I cant recommend any ncr knowledge park based b schools in this score card. If luckily you find one, kindly inform me after passing out with a quality placement so that I can recommend others.If sales is your goal you can go anywhere.There is no substitute of hardwork.
Best of luck,
Subhajit
Hello sir, i got selected in IBA bangalore and in bibs(certificates from NSE and pwc internship).Please
ReplyDeletesuggest me which one to chose.I will go for finance.
Hii Sudipto,
DeleteHope you read the blog.Now see in case of this tier II,check whether you are a chooser or make a tough fight to get the seat(it is very common thing which comes wasily is not worthy,may be wife or College). Conciliate yourself and check whether you choose it or consultancy coerce you to do so.I construed that as if I were in your situation how do I make analysis.
I could not find any potential or coherent reason to join IBA(if I am wrong I will be happy)Bangalore,I heard just from you and go through some about this. Your field is finance as deciphered.So hardly core finance companies name are coming in that case (Kindly ensure from college how many recuitment has been done at XL Dynamics or JP Morgan profile).In our time 3 yr ago XL dyanmics arrange a pull campus(they will come a particular college and other college students have to go there)and their interview criteria was 65% in graduation,aptitude test then Subject round,HR round and no one was selected from 5 college in that day! So ask iba which year they come,profile offered and how many selection was so far.In my friends average Delhi based college ,the famous gurgaon office based American Ex**** came with sales profile with 12,000 in hand offer ( our college show the name it in every in every presentaion,poster flamboyantly !
In our Delhi based college a famous foreign based De**** bank offee sales profile and the candidate resign within few month due to sales pressure. College again make it a whimper to lure new students.
Now coming ti BIBS,it was good in our time(3yr ago) at least they were not foisting finance guy to hardcore financial sales,initial in hand was not good but if posting is Kolkata then you can manage a congruous life style as per lowest living cost.
But I donot know the previous placement officer is there or not.If he still there,you can rely. Dont get manipulated by NSE cerfct or foreign univ collaboration,student exchage(these are just beautifull packaging not product). Focus in product as interviewer want to show you not your certificates but pwc internship is good opportunity. You can also think MDI murshidabad. It is nascent but doing well with mdi gurgaon brand name.Remember for finance core graduation percentage is also a screening criteria by mnc having white collar job offer of domain finance.
It is not an face to face meet so eerything cant be fortified here as this is an open medium.I tried my best to guide you.
Check this and make a prudent decision before taking investment risk.
Best wishes;
শুভজিৎ
please let me know what is your opinion on kirloskar harihar/pune.
ReplyDeleteSorry to disappoint you but I have not heard about this.Check and catch college alumni in linkedin and ask(not current students)
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteHello, My son got selected in St. Xavier's University, newtown for MBA.As this will be the 1st MBA batch so do you think it will be a good decision to study there because of the brand? The total cost is 12.5 lakh.My son already took admission in BIBS
DeleteThanks for patience.BIBS finance was good in our time 13-15 but donot know whether the same placement officer is still there or not. Make a query about this from college. As Xaviers is nascent stage and not even a single passed out batch is there plus cost is too much as this is MBA(university progrm not autonomous and it is Kolkata where cost should be more low. I will not choose Xaviers only for Xavier brand or social status as there is a difference between Xaviers Kolkata to Xaveirs college Burdwan. May be xaviers can do well but I cant trust with this high risk without any visible proof. Ask your son to open a linkedin app account where he can join the BIBS /Xaviers students profile and ask them directly abput this dolemma.You can get the initial amount back as per AICTE norms if you think that you son's profile (Sales,Finance,HR )is not good as per student /alumni view of linkedin. You can check MDI murshidabad also(MDI Gurgaon brunch)but ask him to find college according to his field of MBA choice.
DeleteHope it works.
Thank you
Hello sir!! I got 658.50 marks (86.17 percentile) in the Sept Mat 2018 exam. I got a mail from NDIM new Delhi for the GD/PI session .So should I participate in that and register for the process?? Moreover sir actually I am quite unsure whether I might score good in Cat as I usually get 50 percentile in the mocls that I give so I have lost all hope to crack Cat now!! Hence am focusing on Mat rather! So what should I do sir??
ReplyDeleteHe i also appeared for September MAT but i have not got my results till now and i don't have a idea when will i get my results 😞
DeleteHii Sreyashi,
DeleteWish you a happy Durga puja in advance !
Hope you read the blog properly.
I will not go there at any cost, even in our time 13-15 it has bulk of students admission tendenecy by which it gives in such companies which has hire and fire policy rapidly. Request you to appear in CMAT also as it is conducted by Govt agency aicte by which you will get upeer category sound college. I have covered all most all the dark side which college will not show you before admission. The in campus story is not good not only for this college but maximum greater noida knowledge park based colleges. Ihave given a tier I list there,try to get them through healthy score card. So go for Dec mat and CMat once again. Try to avoid free consultamcy advice,they will just push you in wrong college with flamboyant dream and make cut money from college.
Can you tell me what are the placements of ITM navi Mumbai as I m expecting 90+ in MAT
ReplyDeleteIn our time 13-15 sales is good but core finace placement was bad,so if core finance is your cup of tea check the alumni through linkedin profile chat as investment is huge here.Seat for dec mat and CMaT (organised by govt so higher value)to get better option
ReplyDeleteSir i am interested for both HR and marketing field . So can you suggest some good B School from Mumbai
ReplyDeleteDear Anonymous,
DeleteTry to read my above post including the comment discussion. You will find some Mumbai or Maharashtra based college. Try to get into them. Otherwise I could not find any valuable college through Mat/Cmat and if you are good as a sales person /sales man then choose Mktg(also ensure a 2 wheeler with license for you).Core Makreting profile is not avail in tier II college,so it is hardcore sales mainly,salary in hand is avergae good but too frequesntly hire and fire. If you like offixe based job then choose HR,here in hand salary is not so handsome but job stability is not bad,though exact HR profile is disappearing from tier II mat cmat colleges. Read the blog/ comment again and make a sound descision.
All the best.
Sir I had a score of 692.50 in December mat and a percentile of 92.69....
ReplyDeleteI have been selected for Xime Bangalore and would like to go for operation as my specialisation....should I go forward wid Xime?? I also gave the entrance test for IBS and now they have called me for gd/pi to be held in the month of February....so should I go with Xime or wait for IBS??? Xime has asked me to confirm my seat within 12th Jan 2019 and so I am totally confused as to where to head now!!
Plz help sir
Also sir with this mat score in mind could u suggest some other colleges if not Xime or IBS!!
Hii Shreyashi,Wish you a very smiley new year.If I were you,defintly go for Xime than Icfai. Try to get Finance and HR in Xime.If you are enough sure about the huge investment return of Icfai then can think. If in dilemma go for Xime bangalore,at least I will do this.
DeleteNext suggestion ,would like to advice thatColleges are upgrading to CMAT from Mat so check my previous discussions and the blog mentioned colleges. You can have the best Mat from the above mentioned.
Best wishes
Sir I have scored 58 percentile overall in CAT which actually dropped due to English section otherwise have better score in Quant and DILR section which is above 75%ile in both. I have lately come across this article of yours and am now super nervous about will I get good ROI if I will enroll in some B-schoool like I have LPU in my mind.I shortlisted many more colleges like Amity Noida,JIMS rohini,JIMs kalkaji,FIIB Delhi but unsure if they will take me to their college or not. Sir can you please suggest some good colleges for me and also if there is any good college that takes admission directly with their WAT or with management quota.
ReplyDeleteHii Priyanka,Dont get disappointed to know the reality from this article,you are fortunate enough that before investing you have checked.It is ruefull and sorry to hear that this article of mine is not a happy moment for you,but knowing reality is better before getting married na ?
DeleteLets have a light moment for you,check this two and got their inner meaning in the wrpper of comedy. It surely make some sense to you.
https://youtu.be/Z73RzO4h87g
https://youtu.be/RjU7ve8IWfI
You really have make some sense with a smile,you have done well in CAT Quant and DI,you should congratulate yourself for this too,If you have given CMAT then check the above mentioned colleges(in article and comment section)according to your stream. If you have not given then try to have a job to gain experience then take a bypass route of executive mba from IIM.I will not go the above any rather than giving CAT Quant class to others :) Revert me after watching those two in youtube :) We experineced from life after suffering,you can enjoy it as show.
Best wishes
Surely you can be happy in this new year....
Hello sir, i got 98 percentile in mat and want to know the colleges suitable for me,i don't have any financial support i should afford loan for admission. I'm Agricultural engineer can u list some of the tier1 colleges for me
ReplyDeleteHii Deepu,Wish you very good luck in this new year.I understand your problem. You can go through the colleges which are mentioned in blog and various below comments. Some of these colleges have decided only to allow cmat from previous year. So first fixed your strem (Sales,HR,Core finance)then check which mentioned colleges are allowing mat for this session. Then make a linkedin profile to catch your college alumni /senior,ask them to get this time in campus reality.So you need this home work,I have shorlisted and mentioned only those colleges which accept 95+score(may have little bit change in criteria,ask directly in college faceboom page).Hope your loan burden will give you a fruitfull result. Read the comment discussions attentively.Try to avoid college review in education site,as many time junior students are coerced to write the win win thing by placement officer.
DeleteBesi wishes,
Subhajit
Hello sir, i got 89.92 percentile in mat and want to know the colleges suitable for me in finance sector
ReplyDeleteI will go for Xime bangalore if not then Xime Kochi. Though request you to check the present in campus reality by making a linkedin profile and catch the current students and seniors.In our time,2 yr ago Xime bagalore and Xime kochi was good enough through MAT. During choice try to avoid college purpoted review,in tier II bschool the students are asked to write win win situation by colleges,maximum case its not genuine for tier II colleges.
DeleteSir I have a interest for Operations and related streams like logistics,analytics and supply chain.
ReplyDeleteI recently have my gd/pi rounds for ITM,CHRIST UNIVERSITY,JAIN UNIVERSITY and ICFAAI....So keeping operations in mind what should be my priority line for these colleges if I am able to clear their interviews??
I am really confused!! And if u have some better options sir kindly state that also for specialisation in operations.
Mat Dec score: 692.50 (92.69 percentile)
I will go for Xime bangalore,as you have already selected.Cant take risk with IBS with such huge intake and fees.Try to avoid online or offline web/portal student review as in many cases junior student and current students are asked by authority to write such win win things in review.You can go through the blog mentioned colleges,so read the blog again with comments discussion of various college. In tier II logistics is no more an attractive profile than hard core sales of client finding job. If you are ok with this then go or check the job prifle from seniors of the college through linkedin profile. In a lighter note check this https://youtu.be/Z73RzO4h87g
DeleteHope this will help.
Sir , I have scored 68.87 in cat this year , I am a b.com graduate and I am really confused between these colleges : JIMS rohini , NDIM Delhi , Amity Noida , Army institute Kolkata , FOSTIIMA Delhi ? Can you please help me , also I am planning to apply for NIT trichy and PIBM Pune , how are these two for MBA in marketing ?
ReplyDeleteYou have done good enough being a bcom guy.In this case I will go for Army institute Kolkata(probably 20% seats are avail for general except army family,kindly check the updated data).Army institute is better than the rest,also try xime kochi if possible,at least I will do that.Hope you read the entire blog attentively,there some colleges are mentioned also,can think those if they permit your score card.
DeleteSir i have scored 52 percentile in dec mat and my graduation score is 70%. My interest is in finance.
ReplyDeleteI was thinking to take admission in NDIM or IP univ or ITS or IMS but now after reading article i am so confused. Please help me out. I want to join this year only.
I cant say about IP Univ but have seen IMS,ITS and Ndim alumni from very close even we used to talk in linkedin. If you are desperate for degree only then go there if job is your serious concern try to do better in FRB Mat and get at least Xime Kochi.At least I will do it in my case.
DeleteChoice is yours,i cant suggest you any college with this score card.
Best wishes,
Subhajit
Great post Subhajit Mitra! Commendable
ReplyDeleteThanks Sayarnil,If it is helpful to you,my ambition is successfull.Objective was we suffered three year ago being a gullible candidate why juniors... Thanks for the salutation remark :)
DeleteI read your article on quota & it's really gave me clarity about bschools advt &the reality.. i want to know Which is the best college for pgdm ?IPE hyd or ubs mumbai or asia Pacific delhi?
ReplyDeleteHii VK,Glad to know than my eye pener mission helped you. In our time 3 yr ago IPE finance was good,I have not heard anything negative about UBS Mubai. I will not go Asia pacific.Hope you got an idea.Request you to make a linkedin profile and catch the fresh alumni network to check present in campus reality.
DeleteBest wishes,
Subhajit
Tq
DeleteMy Feb mat score is 741.5 98%tile .I have done Btech . Please,suggest me good college for mba marketing in West Bengal through mat.
ReplyDeletePlease help me I am totally confused.
Hii unknown,
DeleteTake greetings of the day.In your case I will try Army institute and Mdi murshidabad. They were performing well in our time (2.5 yr ago). As you are interested in sales so make sure to have 2 wheeler with license.
Best wishes,
Subhajit
Sir,can you guide which college is better, ITS Ghaziabad or IIMS pune,i got less in 12th grade 51% but have 75% in 10th and 60% plus in graduation Bsc.IT as well Msc.IT ..am planning for marketing as major and IT minor...ty for helping out...those website have mostly or present college student reviews... God bless u
ReplyDeleteHii Divyanshu,Read the blog attetively.Hope you have a healthy CMAT score card,I cant say about IIMS pune,as did not hear too much but could not recommend you ITS as in our time (~3yr ago)it has lost its sheen from senior batches due to too much admission intake.I will not go there betr to do an SIP investment in SBI with safe return. I request you to read the blog and comment,as per my best knowledge I was trying to give a glimpse of good one colleges there,choose according to score card.
DeleteAs you have IT,but in case of marketing you may get software sales/corporate sales job (if you are not thinking tier II CAT)which is not very easy(they avoid the word tough and put a buttery one as 'challenging job' ,so if you are ok with sales then think Mktg and IT combination.
Try to avoid the fear sales approach by consultancy that'seats are going out,immediately submit deamnd draft to reserve your seat' etc trap.
Best wishes
Subhajit
Nomoskar Subhajit dada amar nam Deep. Ami ei bochor pgdm eer jonyo kolkatay 3 te college e selected. Calcutta Business School Globsyn Business School Prxis Business School. Ami ei tin ter beparei valo r onek kharap reviews peyechi. Unfortunately kichu family problems er jonyo ami kolkatar baire jete parbo na. tai egulor modhey konta select kora vlo hbe bujhtei parchi na??? Khub Confused r ghete achi. Help chai as soon as possible.
ReplyDeleteহাই দীপ,
Deleteধন্যবাদ ব্লগটি পড়ার জন্য।আমি হলে তিনটের কোনটিতে যেতাম না কারণ সেক্ষেত্রে তুই আর্মি ইনস্টিটিউট কলকাতা,mdi murshidabad বা পয়সা সমস্যা না হলে imi kolkata ভাবতে পারো কিতু একই লেভেল উপরন্তু আরও ভালো প্লেসমেন্ট অনেক কম খরচে iiswb&m kolkata (college st)এ পাবে যদি cat থাকে তবে সম্ভবত iiswb&m আর নেবে না তবে নজর রেখো।ব্লগটি আবার পড়ো এবং পয়েন্ট গুলো মাথায় রাখিস। দরকার হলে দশ লাখ টাকা sbi sip তে ইনভেএস্ট করে মান্হলি গ্যারান্টি ইনকাম করে নেওয়া ভালো আজেবাজে কলেজে পয়সা নষ্ট থেকে। আর সিট নেই তাড়াতাড়ি ড্রাফট জমা দাও এই ধরনের কথার ফাদে পড়িস না।যদি কখনও মনে হয় কলকাতার বাইরে যেতে পারবি সেখানে manipal institute of banking ভাবতে পারিস,সরকারী ব্যাঙ্কে ক্যান্ডিডেট নেওয়া হয় এখান থেকে তবে ibps পরিচালিত পরীক্ষায় বসে ওখানে পড়ার সুযোগ পাবে।
Se toh thik i IISWBM MDI murshidabad Army egulo sobtheke valo but egulo te porar mto oto valo percentile nei amar ar IMI te porar moto oto samorthyo nei. Baire jeteo parbo na. Egulor modhey thekei kta bachte hobe. Jai hok CBS 6.85 Globsyn 7.5 ar Praxis 9.27(hostel noe) nichhe.....egulo chara r kno options e nei....kaje dhorei nichhi monder valo jodi bachai korte hoy tahole egulor modhey konta jawa uchit?? Loke bole j praxis er faculty naki khub i vlo besir vag iit iim theke pora r porano, globsyn e naki company besi ase....jai hok ek ek jon ek ek rokom kotha bole...
Deleteআমি হলে কোথাও যেতাম না,সম্ভব হলে এক বছর ছেড়ে আবার এন্টার্স দিতাম(cat সহ)।তবুও আণাদের সময় শেষের দিকে প্রাসেন্টাইল যারা BIBS ফাইনান্স নেয় তাদের মোটামুটি খারাপ হয় নি জব। জানিনা সেই প্লেসমেন্ট অফিসার এখনও আছেন কি না।সেটা চেক করে নিয়ে Bibs ভাবতে পারো। তবে ভালো ফ্যাকাল্টি হলেই ভালো প্লেসমেন্ট আসে না সেটা প্লেসমেন্ট অফিসারের ওপর নির্ভর করে। দুর্বল প্লেসমেন্ট ঢাকতে ফ্যাক্আল্টি বেশি করে হাইলাইট করাটাও একটা ট্যাকটিক্স।
Deleteআমি হলেযেতাম না তবে শেষ অবধি bibs একবার ভাবতে পারো,এই তিনটের থেকে তুলনামূলক ভাবে ভালো যদি 2015 র সেই একই প্লেসমেন্ট অফিসার থেকে থাকেন।হয়তো একটু কঠোর শোনাচ্ছে তবে সত্যেই এহেন অবস্হায় আমিও কিংকর্তব্যবিমূঢ় কিছুটা।মে মাসে আর একটু ভালো কলেজ গুলো ফাঁকা থাকনা সেটাও বুঝতে পারছো...গ্লোব নিজেদেরও সিস্টার কম্পানিতে জব দেয়,ছেলেরা টার্গেট ফুলফিল না করতে পেরে ছেড়ে দেয় ফলে বছর বছর সেটা খালিই থাকে
thank u dada ultimately bujhlm iiswbm,army,mdi murshidabad bad diye kolkatay kichui valo nei...Icfai kolkatar tao thik bujhte parchi na....jai hok thank you dada...eta bujhlm egulor konotai vlo na.....jdi krtei hoy toh jekhane khoroch kom hbe parle sekhane jbo...dekha jak ki hoy...
DeleteMake a wise choice after getting enlighted. Hope this blog and discussion help you. Try to help others also.
DeleteBest wishes,
Subhajit
Hello sir,I have scored IN ATMA 70.55 percentile,so which college in pune and other states of India for MBA in finance with good placement.
ReplyDeleteI am really unable to help you,as it is beyond my knowledge.Please understand you cant expect an iPad with 5,000 budget,either you have to wait for the budget or get satisfied with chinese one.
DeleteIf you get one,I will be really happy and let us know about that colg so that we can guide others.
Read the blog again.
Feel free to write.
Advice you to try for betr score in Sept Mat or CMAT
Hello Subhajit da. You have written a very good article.
ReplyDeleteMy name is Shubham Bhagat and i have completed my BCA in 2018 with 7.15 DGPA. At college i was not thinking of MBA at all, as i ioped that i will get a job. But, the barriers were my 10th and 12th marks. They are below 60%, which was mainly the cutoff for maximum companies. Now after final semester, i had nothing to do, and then i thougt of appearing for CAT and doing MBA. I missed out on CAT2018 as i was not even prepared. I appeared for FEB MAT 2019 (without any preparation), and i got 73.51 percentile. My main motive for MAT was to get accustomed to these sort of examinations. Now at this time of the year, almost all my friends have either got into job or got into college for MBA. Here i am sitting idle at home without any motivation to study and now I am looking to get admission in PIBM with my existing MAT marks. Sir, i have lost all my hopes wondering that i wont be able to crack CAT with some super percentile which will fetch me a Tier-1 college. Even if i i wa again for one more year, my profile will get destroyed due to 2 years gap with actually nothing i have done. Even if i score well, i might not get selected in the GD-PI because of my bad profile.
Sir, please help me out ASAP. I am suffering a lot due to this and i am constantly getting depressed due to this. 😭
Hii Subham,
DeleteTake a hug and greetings from me. You should know bro 'early bird does not always have survival advantage' Having a job and enjoying life is dream now a days. Either the early job holder is not happy in maximum cases with the job proifle or he has no time for life.
I dont know which place you belong to but if you are from Delhi,may have observed the 8/9yr struggle of IAS aspirants in Mukherjee nagar or their mess in Lakshminagar. They become a zombie saint/baba after studying too much,so put your feet in their shoes and think. I understand you are feeling bad to see frndz fb enjyment/party/marriage etc but happiness is not show off,think that you have to work for 8/9hour for 6 days and then saturday night disk/bar/escort and facebook status "feeling happy"
Yes,money matters obviously andl you will make it,but you are absorbing too much negativity by self,drop out/gap is very common practice in our diversified(confused!)education system.Cat/Neet/IIT entrances have many gap year. Just answer the reason with confident,say the truth just even your marks are also improving why do you think so and who are those rubbish corporates whoss HR guys just put this % screening criteria to reduce their work load.
Check even world's one of the toughest exam UPSC Civil service do not reject the drop out/gap year guys.
https://www.newsbytesapp.com/timeline/India/47648/216456/these-people-overcame-failures-challenges-to-become-civil-servants/amp/google
I undsdstand their criteria may be a problem for your rapid growth but you can take a bypass route,one my college friendshave just 44% from Calcutta university then even tier II college he got sales profile of banking prodcuct,he somehow manage to join a single room accounts firm as accountant in Karolbagh,Delhi after 3 year he joined the giant firm KPMG(he was rejected first for not having 55% in graduation).
So there are ampke number of choices,even now he quit it and become a tax advisor for freelancing,as he wanted a job with life.People used to take gap yr for CAT,sp you can attempt next cat with CMAT. As maximum MAT tier I colleges shifted in CMAT.One of my linked in friend was from PIBM(not in contact now) theri batch has to suffer much for a rubbish in hand and lifestyle in mumbai is too rogid also .Check if the situation has improved or not then go,attempt CMAT also.
Take a few days tour to your favourite place (try to avoid mobile/smartphone)nad leave the all neagtivity in that hotel room and do watch some jio fimfare short films in youtube. Try to avoid social media/whts app,it is just a musk/show off by your friends.Practice simple text.
Remember there is a difference between a real friend and non enemy friend,if you made a non enemy as friend,its your mistake.
Love life,best wishes
Subhajit
Sir could you please suggest some good colleges based on mat September score . Mat percentile is 97.83
ReplyDeleteCongrats ! U have good score card but dont skip the CMAT score,it has more weight to tier I B schools. Kindly resd the commnet/discussions with students in this blog and choose the suggested b school,which is more suitable for u according to your core field.
DeleteTry to avoid consultancy call.Hope this blog is helpfull to you
sir I m confused between mba and pgdm ...I cannot make out which one to go for?
ReplyDeleteDear Unknown,Read the blog again,even read the comment section discussions attentively. I am sure u will find your cup of tea. Though you can also check my answer...
Deletehttps://www.quora.com/Which-course-is-better-MBA-or-PGDM/answers/39786347?ch=10&share=8ebcba6d&srid=pg0x6
I like how you have described the different aspects one needs to check while selecting B Schools for studies. Most people ignore the factors you have mentioned like placement through third party or hire and fire type placements. The post will help candidates make better choices regarding B-Schools. Next time use some images too. Visit: https://www.itm.edu/
ReplyDeleteThanks for ur words.We have an unexpected number of viewers here.But we cant entertain any promotion of college in comment section untill we get some good reviews from horse's mouth.Though we have decided to keep it for few time for your notice.
DeleteSincerely Yours,
Subhajit
Thank You
Sir, now my age is 31 year. My last qualification is B.tech in ME (2018 pass out) from MAKAUT with DGPA 7.53. I have 2 years of work experience after graduation. But 5 years of experience before graduation ( I don't know it will consider or not). I will give MAT february 2020.
ReplyDeleteNow I am anxious that is it a good decision to do MBA at this age ? should I prepare for CAT 2020 for good B School? That time my age will be 32 years. Please give some suggestions.
I want to do my MBA through education loan as my financial condition and present CTC is not good. (my 10th & 12th marks is 66.25 and 86.2% respectively.)
Regards
Abhisek Bhattacharjee
Dear Sir,If your CAT score is average(You will get a hints from mock test during last month of preperation)then go to executive MBA of ISB and continue the present job.Job experience should have relevance with your MBA choice of field.Age does not matter as you have work exp and even in state govt,many employees join 35+ age due to high competition.
DeleteTry also CMAT and check which bschools of this blog matches your score card.Only having the score card you can make decision,nobody can presume the exam hall environemnt and candidate performance within that golden hour.
Best wishes,
Subhajit
Kolkata-59
Thanks for your answer. I got 638.50 in Feb Mat 81.30 percentile. Is it a good decision to join
Delete1. XIME(any campus) or XBS kolkata.
2. IPE Hyderabad or NIT Shilchar.
3. DBS or IIEST Shibir.
Hello Shubhajit! first of all i would like to thank-you for putting up this article because it is very essential to know beforehand what we as mba aspirants are getting ourselves into.
ReplyDeleteI gave MAT in 2018 and scored around 90% and almost got into Christ Banglore, i opted out becuase they were not being flexible in their policy. I decided to take some time before i proceeded to take education loan. Things could go worse when you have the headache of paying installments every month. After i dropped out of Christ I decided to continue my study and appear in govt exams mainly Banks SSC's and related exams.
I come from a commerce background and Quant has been my nemesis throughout these years. My overall education background is good but i suffer in Quant, hence i haven't done well in CAT.
So this year (2020) i have given CMAT in jan and i and I am also attempting MAT(FEB)
I want to pursue a career in marketing but not in marketing sales profile.
Keeping in mind the education loan req to peruse my mba please suggest some colleges.
I had shortlisted BIMM,CHRIST,SIES NAVI MUMBAI in 2018.
Is XIME banglore or BIMTECH worth considering keeping in mind that their fee structure is huge and would put additional pressure.
I am expecting CMAT SCORE of anywhere b/w 193-213.
AND MAT above 90%
Please do Respond as I am looking for some insight before i make the decesion.
Dear Unknown,
DeleteThanks for reading.You said "I decided to appear in Govt exams Bank Ssc" Dont play gamble and I defntly congratualte u that you have shown enough strength to opt out after investing money.
I dont know ssc/Govt job or CMATis ur goal,but take a firm decision and stick on it.If ur CMAT is not good then obviously roll back to Govt ssc.There also u have to give time and keep patience,u have to face social gathering and Society/Relatives with the most unwlecomed question 'What are u doing now ' ? Or simly sayingv"Pancahyet in your life".This is very common to all NEET/CAT/UPSC/Bank job aspirants.
Now coming to your College,I will go to Xime balore HR and Finance and Bimtech for marketing. But it is tough to get market research /brand marketing job core job profile.So I will asvice you to choose core Finance -Xime Blore.(As you said its tough for u to take the fee pressure then Pubma/Simsree like college and Few NIT's could be the solution,though the nit's are struggling during placmnt as they are nascent in this field being a techie institute. I think you want corporate type finance job with marketing profile,due to some reason. But solution is Finance,as nobody knows whether the Market resrch prfl will be available during your placmnt season or not.
At least I will do this.
This is not an ultmt solution but from best of my knowledge.So good score card can help you to get rid of high investment risk.
Best wishes,
Subhajit
Kolkata-59
hey subhajit, thank-you for reverting back and also for suggestions regarding the same.
ReplyDeleteMy CMAT score Is Around 80% and i am still waiting for my Mat score.
I am not sure of whether i should take loan of above 10 lacs, that is the primary reason for me to back out on Christ and that stands in way of my decision On BIMTECH and XIME'S.
their tuition fees stands tall at about 16 lacs and with interest on loan, margin fees etc will go upto somewhere around 25-30 lacs. I am not sure that this is worth the investment and also how feasible would it be to repay such an ammount living in Major metro cities.
Are there any other alternatives in colleges such AS BIMM NIA Pune UBS SIESCOM that i can take?
Also clearing govt job requires patience among other skills.
So i am thinking about persuing MBA this year and then jump start my career in the field, also i am looking for MBA in Marketing and IB as my specialization.
From the above mentioned colleges recommend what you think should work out the best for me.
Hii percent,Sorry for late reply due to unavoidable circumstances and busy schedule.
DeleteEither we have enough good score card to avoid the the fee pressure. Only merit can dominate money in many(not maximum as now a days tier I colleges want to be self sufficient from Govt) cases,not disappointing you but its hard reality.
Again I can advice you to check the comment section colleges which can satisfy your parameters in terms of fee and ranking balance sheet.
Marketing and IB is not good combo in teir II colleges,as the colleges mentioned by you. IB or International Business is a just flamboyant vocabulary if you have no family run export business. Otherwise you have to endure in one or two room small firm and their pathetic work culture,it looks like a relation between slave and master(not all but in maximum cases). In Kolkata there are ample number of Marwari firms for that but people cant sustain there and The bluechip MNC like Amazon to Maersk would not allow your college.
In this case Marketing and Finance(duel not major/minor progrm)could be betr as after reading the subject and getting into intership,the hard reality can help you to choose between Mktg and Finace,which one is your cup of tea. Trust me,before getting in the campus you are not in the position to choose IB/Finance etc from now. Dream and reality is diffrent.
One more advice,make a linkedin profile and inbox your favrt college alumni about the in campus reality. Leave a professional msgs there. Kindly make a genuine profile with right info and Picture to get revert from them.Make bank loan asset not burden of family.
Besi wishes,
Subhajit
Kolkata-59
Thanks for reading and understanding. Best wishes
ReplyDeleteSubhajit
Kolkata-59
Thanks for your answer. I got 638.50 in Feb Mat 81.30 percentile. Is it a good decision to join
ReplyDelete1. XIME(any campus) or XBS kolkata.
2. IPE Hyderabad or NIT Shilchar.
3. DBS or IIEST Shibir.
Which one should I do ? Or can you suggest any others?
Amid Covid 19 situation is diffrent,though I will try Xime Bnagalore ror Finance,then IPE for finace. Again I repeat we cant calculate post Covid placement situation,at least after 7/8 month we get an some campus story
DeleteSir Ami 2bar graduation korechi 1st time less marks peyechi ta to Amar kono problem hbe MBA korle?
ReplyDeleteProblem is not degree bt we cant put any placement equation right now after Covid 19 impact on our economy. May be corporates become too much coherent to select for few posts. Degree will not be problem but we cant say abput placement or stable job profile.
DeleteTRY TO AVOID CONSULTANCY. READ THE BLOG AND COMMENT SECTION DISCUSSIONS AGAIAN
Impact in Placement or stable job profile, on account of covid 19 as it effect in economy for that???or only in my case....
ReplyDeletesir can u tell me how is IIRM Hyderabad? its a joint college run by Telangana Govt and IRDAI Govt of India? is MBA worth here?
ReplyDelete